About Me

Name: Thomas More
Loading...

Create Your Own Blog Find Other Townhall Blogs

Comments

Blog Roll

 

Public Funding

 

TmoreThere is a difference between having a constitutional right to something and having the Constitution require the government to pay you for something.  For example, the 2nd Amendment gives you the right to own a gun:  "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."  But there is no constitutional provision, nor is there a case that I know of, that requires Congress to pay for guns for people who want them, but can't afford them.  Whereas with trials, the 6th Amendment does say that a person receive "the Assistance of Counsel for his defence."  Thus, if I can't afford counsel, the Constitution requires the government to pay for one--that's where we get public defenders from.

What, then, does the Constitution say about abortions?  Well, nothing.  As most know, however, the Supreme Court--in Roe v. Wade--found a constitutional right to an abortion in the Constitution--implicitly rather than explicitly.  Thus, Congress and the states, cannot pass laws prohibiting abortions.  Roe, however, does not require Congress or the states to pay for those abortions.  Essentially, if you want one, the government does not have to help you pay for one.  This is true for guns, too.  It is also true for countless other medical procedures--you can get a face lift, tummy tuck, or 'enhancement' all you want, but the government does not have to pay for it.

The distinction between a right to a procedure, and paying for the procedure, seems to be lost on Rudy Giuliani.  When he ran for NYC Mayor, he advocated for public-funding of abortions.  In this recent interview, he stuck by that position:

Rudy Giuliani told CNN Wednesday he supports public funding for some abortions, a position he advocated as mayor and one that will likely put the GOP presidential candidate at odds with social conservatives in his party.

"Ultimately, it's a constitutional right, and therefore if it's a constitutional right, ultimately, even if you do it on a state by state basis, you have to make sure people are protected," Giuliani said in an interview with CNN's Dana Bash in Florida's capital city.

A video clip of the then-mayoral candidate issuing a similar declaration in 1989 in a speech to the "Women's Coalition" appeared recently on the Internet.

"There must be public funding for abortions for poor women," Giuliani says in the speech that is posted on the video sharing site YouTube. "We cannot deny any woman the right to make her own decisions about abortion."  (Emphasis mine.)

He says not paying for an elective procedure is the government "denying" a right. 


Read on HERE.

Thomas More

allthesemore@yahoo.com
Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive